“Untuk apa.
Saya sudah selesai. Kamu mau apa lagi sih.”Itu jawaban Pak Johan Silas, seorang “Professor” ketika saya datang ke rumahnya di Surabaya pada 2025 dan menawarkan sebuah kuliah umum bersama OMAH Library.
👆Saya mengenal namanya sejak mahasiswa, dari halaman Kampung Improvement Program di Archnet. ✌️Bertahun-tahun kemudian, setiap kali saya bertanya kepada kawan tentang figur di Surabaya, nama yang muncul selalu sama. 🤘Maka saya menghubungi beliau, dan beliau menerima saya di rumahnya.
Orang yang berkata sudah selesai itu menjelang 90 tahun dan masih mengajar. Kami mengobrol berkali-kali, dan ceritanya selalu sama. Gang kampung yang lebarnya 2 meter. Jakarta yang kehilangan kampungnya. Disertasi yang tidak ada pengujinya. Awalnya saya mengira ini pengulangan orang tua.
Belakangan saya membaca wawancara Freek Colombijn dengan beliau, terbit 2016 di jurnal Indonesia dari Cornell.
Di ujung wawancara Colombijn bertanya, beliau ini penulis, guru, arsitek, atau perencana kota. Jawabannya, “I am a singer.” Ia menjelaskan apa yang dikerjakan orang dan apa isi sebuah kota, katanya, tapi bukan ia yang membuat semua itu terjadi.
Penyanyi memang mengulang lagunya. Yang saya dengar di ruang tamu itu adalah repertoar. Maka pertanyaan saya berubah, dari kenapa ia mengulang menjadi lagu mana yang benar.
👆Gang kampung Surabaya dibuat 2 meter supaya ambulans bisa masuk. Jalan mobil cukup tiap 300 meter karena selang pemadam menjangkau 150 meter. Angka yang sama ia sebut kepada Colombijn pada 2015 dan di ITS pada 2025.
✌️Kampung Kebalen meraih Aga Khan Award pada 1986. Disertasinya di ITB memang tertahan 3 tahun karena sekolah pascasarjana tidak sanggup membentuk tim penguji. Ia akhirnya lulus lewat 6 buku yang terbit internasional. Sebagian lagi meleset.
🤘Di ITS ia bercerita tentang Rockefeller yang wafat di usia 94, padahal 97. Ia bercerita tentang pemuda keturunan India yang perusahaannya dibeli Meta, padahal pendirinya anak imigran Tiongkok dan Meta membeli 49%. Angkanya salah, moralnya utuh. Begitulah cerita lisan bekerja. Hanya saja, di kuliah yang sama ia menertawakan profesor yang banyak menulis tanpa jejak nyata.
Yang paling menarik adalah lagu yang ia koreksi sendiri.
👋Di kuliah, Surabaya terdengar bijak karena menolak jalan mobil di kampung, sementara Jakarta membangunnya lalu kehilangan kampung. Kepada Colombijn ia mengaku waktu itu mereka tidak tahu. Jalan mobil ditolak hanya supaya uang tidak terbuang untuk jalan yang tidak dibutuhkan orang.
Surabaya memang tidak punya uang, dan ia menyebut itu berkah terselubung. Program perbaikan kampung pada awalnya bahkan dibiayai lotre kota, Lotto Surya.😳

Hasil yang baik lahir dari keterbatasan, lalu diceritakan ulang sebagai prinsip.🥹
Lalu soal penyanyi yang katanya tidak membuat apa pun terjadi. Tahun 1965, sesudah G30S, sebuah jip Kodim datang ke rumahnya pagi-pagi. Tetangganya mengira ia diciduk. Yang memanggil adalah Letkol Sukotjo, komandan Kodim yang baru menjadi penjabat wali kota. Sukotjo mengaku hanya dilatih berperang dan butuh rencana untuk mengurus kota. Silas menyusun master plan itu bersama kawan dan mahasiswanya.
Sejak itu ia tidak pernah jauh dari balai kota. Ia menulis pidato Wali Kota Purnomo Kasidi dan ikut dalam perjalanannya ke luar negeri. Ketika pengusaha menyodorkan uang kepada wali kota, wali kota meneleponnya, dan uang itu menjadi pusat budaya dan rumah susun sewa. Pada 2010 kelompoknya mendorong Tri Rismaharini, bekas mahasiswanya, menjadi calon wali kota di menit terakhir. Penyanyi itu ternyata ikut menulis lagunya.
🥹Ini siasat, dan siasat ada harganya.
Warga bantaran sungai ia beri pilihan, dan ketika mereka terlambat memilih, pilihannya tinggal rumah susun atau digusur. Ketika Colombijn bertanya apakah hubungannya dengan wali kota terlalu dekat, ia hanya menjawab bahwa Surabaya baik-baik saja.
Di ITS ia keras terhadap Jakarta dan ibu kota baru. Terhadap Surabaya, tidak.
🥹Ibu kota baru itu membuatnya sedih, katanya, karena megah dan dibangun saat penduduk menyusut.
Tapi di kuliah yang sama ia membanggakan sebuah kota baru yang lain. Ia terlibat dalam konsep Kuala Kencana, kota milik Freeport di Timika yang diresmikan Soeharto pada 1995, sekitar 17.000 hektare di tengah hutan dengan semua kabel ditanam. Curitiba, yang sering disebut kota lingkungan terbaik di dunia, menurutnya tidak ada apa-apanya dibanding Kuala Kencana.
Pada 2023 Freeport menyebut para perencana ibu kota baru datang belajar ke sana. Kota yang ia banggakan dipakai sebagai contoh untuk kota yang ia sedihkan. Bedanya, menurut ukurannya sendiri, ada pada skala. Kuala Kencana kecil dan melayani sebuah pekerjaan, sedangkan ibu kota baru hendak memindahkan 1,5 juta orang. 🥹
Tapi Kuala Kencana juga kebalikan dari kampung. Kampung menurutnya adalah tempat orang tetap dikenal.🥹
Di Kuala Kencana fasilitas dipakai dengan kartu perusahaan, dan warga Timika masuk dengan menitipkan KTP di pos. Ia berkata menyediakan kawasan agar suku Kamoro membangun sendiri. Pada tahun kota itu diresmikan, tokoh Amungme dan Kamoro mendapati catatan pemerintah yang menyebut hampir 1 juta hektare tanah ulayat mereka sudah dilepas, termasuk untuk kota itu.🥹
Saya menyebut cara berpikir ini cerdik cendekia. Cerdik adalah akal membaca situasi. Cendekia adalah ilmu yang bisa diuji.
Gang 2 meter adalah keduanya sekaligus. Anekdot yang meleset dan kedekatan tanpa kritik adalah cerdik yang berjalan sendirian.
😳Ia belajar cara itu dari kampung, tapi ia bukan orang kampung. Masa kecilnya di Surabaya, katanya, ada di depan sebuah kampung. Dari depan itulah ia bekerja seumur hidup, cukup dekat untuk mendengar warga dan cukup dekat dengan kuasa untuk melindungi mereka.
Kuliah itu akhirnya terjadi di ITS pada Selasa, 26 Agustus 2025, dengan judul Masa Depan Kampung dan Kota Indonesia. Penyelenggaranya Laboratorium Perumahan dan Permukiman ITS, Jaringan Arsip Arsitektur Indonesia, dan OMAH Library.
Menjelang akhir, moderator bertanya apakah seseorang harus menjadi arsitek sukses dulu, baru mengurus kampung. Ia memakai nama saya sebagai contoh arsitek sukses itu. Pak Silas tidak menjawab ya atau tidak. Ia bernyanyi.
👆Rockefeller yang kaya raya divonis hidup setahun lagi, lalu mendirikan yayasan dan hidup sampai tua. Uang bukan segala-galanya. Jawaban yang lebih pendek ada di hidupnya sendiri. Ia mulai pada usia 29, mengajar di sebuah gudang.
✌️Ia menutup kuliah dengan ukuran yang ia pakai untuk dirinya. Penghargaan terbesar baginya adalah masih dipakai, masih berguna bagi Surabaya. Orang yang berkata sudah selesai itu mengukur hidupnya dari masih atau tidaknya ia dibutuhkan.
Beliau wafat pada 8 Juni 2026, di usia 90 tahun.
Beberapa waktu sebelumnya saya bercerita tentang beliau kepada mama. Mama ternyata kenal. Oma saya orang Samarinda, kota kelahiran beliau, dan beliau masih kerabat jauh dari pihak oma. Pada 1980-an banyak saudara oma merantau ke Surabaya, begitu juga orang tua saya. Pertengahan 1980-an beliau sering datang ke toko kelontong milik adik oma di Dukuh Kupang Timur, hanya untuk mengobrol. 🥹Hidup keluarga mama sedang sulit waktu itu.🤮
Mama sudah lupa detailnya. Yang tersisa hanya bahwa orangnya sederhana dan suka mengobrol.🤘
Pada tahun-tahun itu Kebalen meraih Aga Khan dan ia menulis pidato wali kota. Di toko itu tidak ada yang mencatat.
Saya tidak sempat menyampaikan ini kepada beliau. Saya kira jawabannya akan sama.
Untuk apa.🙏🙏🙏
Sisi yang berkesan bertemu dengan pak Silas, perjumpaan kedua dan terakhir kami dengan beliau :
Satu pribadi sederhana yang langka !
(rs)
The Singer in Front of the Village
What for.
I am done. What else do you want.” That was the answer of Mr. Johan Silas, a “Professor,” when I came to his house in Surabaya in 2025 and offered a public lecture with OMAH Library.
👆I had known his name since my university days, from the Kampung Improvement Program page on Archnet. ✌️Years later, whenever I asked friends about a figure in Surabaya, the name that came up was always the same. 🤘So I contacted him, and he welcomed me at his home.
The man who said he was done was nearing 90 and still teaching. We chatted many times, and the story was always the same. Village alleyways 2 meters wide. Jakarta losing its villages. A dissertation with no examiners. At first I thought this was just an old man’s repetition.
Later I read Freek Colombijn’s interview with him, published in 2016 in the journal Indonesia from Cornell.
At the end of the interview Colombijn asked whether he was a writer, teacher, architect, or urban planner. The answer, “I am a singer.” He explained what people did and what a city contained, he said, but it was not he who made all of that happen.
Singers do repeat their songs. What I heard in that living room was a repertoire. So my question changed, from why he kept repeating to which song was true.
👆Surabaya’s village alleys were made 2 meters wide so ambulances could enter. Car roads every 300 meters are enough because fire hoses reach 150 meters. The exact same numbers he told Colombijn in 2015 and at ITS in 2025.
✌️Kampung Kebalen won the Aga Khan Award in 1986. His dissertation at ITB was indeed delayed for 3 years because the graduate school could not form an examining committee. He finally graduated through 6 books published internationally. Some other details missed the mark.
🤘At ITS he talked about Rockefeller who died at 94, when it was actually 97. He talked about the young Indian-descent man whose company was bought by Meta, when the founders were actually the children of Chinese immigrants and Meta bought 49%. The numbers were wrong, the moral intact. That is how oral history works. Only, in the exact same lecture he mocked professors who write a lot without leaving a real footprint.
The most interesting part is the song he corrected himself.
👋In lectures, Surabaya sounded wise because it rejected car roads in villages, while Jakarta built them and lost its villages. To Colombijn he confessed that at the time they did not know. Car roads were rejected simply so money wouldn’t be wasted on roads people didn’t need.
Surabaya indeed had no money, and he called that a blessing in disguise. The village improvement program was initially even funded by the city lottery, Lotto Surya.😳
Good results are born from limitations, then retold as principles.🥹
Then about the singer who supposedly didn’t make anything happen. In 1965, after G30S, a Kodim jeep came to his house early in the morning. His neighbors thought he was being picked up. The caller was Lieutenant Colonel Sukotjo, the new Kodim commander who had just become the acting mayor. Sukotjo confessed he was only trained to fight and needed a plan to run the city. Silas drafted that master plan together with his friends and students.
Since then he was never far from city hall. He wrote Mayor Purnomo Kasidi’s speeches and joined his trips abroad. When businessmen offered money to the mayor, the mayor called him, and that money became a cultural center and rental apartments. In 2010 his group pushed Tri Rismaharini, his former student, to become a mayoral candidate at the very last minute. The singer apparently helped write her song.
🥹This is a strategy, and every strategy has a cost.
Riverbank residents were given a choice, and when they were late to choose, the only options left were apartments or eviction. When Colombijn asked whether his relationship with the mayor was too close, he only replied that Surabaya was fine.
At ITS he was harsh toward Jakarta and the new capital. Toward Surabaya, no. 🥹
The new capital made him sad, he said, because it was grand and built when the population was shrinking.
But in the same lecture he boasted about another new city. He was involved in the concept of Kuala Kencana, Freeport’s company town in Timika inaugurated by Soeharto in 1995, around 17,000 hectares in the middle of the jungle with all cables buried underground. Curitiba, often called the best environmental city in the world, was nothing compared to Kuala Kencana, according to him.
In 2023 Freeport mentioned that the new capital’s planners came to learn there. The city he was proud of was used as an example for the city he was saddened by. The difference, by his own measure, was scale. Kuala Kencana was small and served a single job, whereas the new capital intended to relocate 1.5 million people. 🥹
But Kuala Kencana was also the antithesis of a kampung. A kampung, according to him, is a place where people remain known. 🥹
In Kuala Kencana facilities were used with company cards, and Timika residents entered by leaving their ID cards at the guard post. He said he provided the area so the Kamoro tribe could build for themselves. In the year that city was inaugurated, Amungme and Kamoro leaders found government records stating that nearly 1 million hectares of their customary land had been released, including for that city. 🥹
I call this way of thinking astute and intellectual. Astuteness is the wit to read situations. Intellectualism is the knowledge that can be tested.
The 2-meter alley is both at once. Anecdotes that miss the mark and uncritical closeness are astuteness walking alone.
😳He learned that way from the village, but he was not a village person. His childhood in Surabaya, he said, was in front of a village. From that front yard he worked all his life, close enough to hear the residents and close enough to power to protect them.
That lecture finally took place at ITS on Tuesday, August 26, 2025, titled The Future of Indonesian Villages and Cities (Masa Depan Kampung dan Kota Indonesia). It was organized by the ITS Housing and Settlement Laboratory, the Indonesian Architecture Archive Network, and OMAH Library.
Toward the end, the moderator asked whether someone must become a successful architect first before taking care of villages. He used my name as an example of that successful architect. Mr. Silas did not answer yes or no. He sang.
👆The wealthy Rockefeller was told he had one year left to live, then founded a foundation and lived to old age. Money isn’t everything. The shorter answer is in his own life. He started at 29, teaching in a warehouse.
✌️He concluded the lecture with the standard he applied to himself. The greatest reward for him was still being used, still being useful to Surabaya. The man who proclaimed himself done measured his life by whether or not he was still needed.
He passed away on June 8, 2026, at the age of 90.
A while back I told my mother about him. Mama turned out to know him. My grandmother was from Samarinda, his birthplace, and he was a distant relative from my grandmother’s side. In the 1980s many of my grandmother’s siblings migrated to Surabaya, just like my parents. In the mid-1980s he often came to my grandmother’s younger sibling’s grocery store in Dukuh Kupang Timur, just to chat. 🥹Mama’s family life was going through a difficult time back then. 🤮
Mama had forgotten the details. What remained was that he was a humble man who loved to chat. 🤘
In those years Kebalen won the Aga Khan and he was writing mayoral speeches. In that store no one was taking notes.
I didn’t get a chance to tell him this. I figure his answer would have been the same.
What for. 🙏🙏🙏
The memorable side of meeting Mr. Silas, our second and last encounter with him.
A rare, humble individual!